Monday, 15 July 2024

Do you want to use AI or be used via AI (2/2)

In my previous post (1), I showed how state actors who have been using propaganda for years to influence what we as individuals think/believe are now getting more aggressive, more targeted and more insidious by using AI/ML bots and social media.

It is still my belief that:

  • Influencing how people behave is nothing new, AI just makes it easier to achieve
  • AI is being used more and more to influence how people think and therefore behave
  • AI is neither good nor bad, it is how it is used that matters.
  • Each one of us has a choice to make, whether to allow the influence or question it

AI is neither good nor bad, neither was fire. It is how it is used that matters, and how we, individually deal with it. For example, it probably is not usual for you to leave flammable stuff next to a gas stove/BBQ, is it? You want to control fire and use it, rather than let is go loose because of error/clumsiness of mind, and cause untold damage.

The battle is for your brain, do you want to lose it?

perchance.org

The most important defense is a sane level of skepticism

People are wired to trust (1). When people’s social circles were small, and tight, you knew the people you interacted well, and their personal characteristics. Add to this mutual benefit (after all you are in a tight knit group), it made sense to trust information that someone in the group relayed to you.

However, the world has evolved from small villages, to global village, add to this the evolution of the press from reporting to giving opinions, and the advent of social media where pretty much anybody can say anything, and you can see that it makes sense to be a little bot skeptical of information you get.

It is ok to be skeptical, but just parking information somewhere is not a good idea.

  • It may be believed since it has stayed in the parking lot for that long or with similar stories
  • You may be suspending action while you are evaluating things (analysis paralysis)

Aside: how processing information has changed over time

This is an aside that is slightly more important than a footnote. One of the interesting things that has changed is HOW people are convinced. In the past, people used to postulate “a theory”, then provide ‘facts’ that support the theory, and therefore the people targeted believe the theory. Nowadays, the focus is in repetition rather than a theory. “There is a low bar to assent and repetition: the conspiracy charge is ‘true enough.’ Subscribers to conspiracy without the theory do not to have to believe the particulars of the charge. Indeed, there are rarely any particulars – just assertion and innuendo.”(2)

Nowadays repetition in social media is designed to burn a factoid into your brain, rather than bring you to a conclusion by starting with a theory. The end result is that a belief or a bias is formed, and given we are lazy, we rarely review the reasons for beliefs we may have. So, repetition, especially at the scale of social media, works.

Back to the main topic.

Simple Steps to protect yourself: 1 trusted sources

I started by using US elections of 2016 as an example (3), and this was deliberate. These two posts were motivated by an article I read recently. (4). The Stanford Internet Observatory was one of the first to pull the alarm on Russian interference in the US 2016 Presidential elections. If you have time, it is worth looking into their efforts (5). Basically, they are stuck in lawsuits, so the university has decided the truth was not worth that amount of money.

There are other possible trusted sources that evaluate factoids you may have heard, fact checking websites; politifact is one of them (6); you can find more (7)

Unfortunately for us outside the USA, many of these are US centric.

For example, how many people in Singapore would have believed, despite all the technological excellence of MAS, the banking sector (including the world’s best digital bank), the rapidity of the police at shutting down crime, SGD3Billion worth of money laundering took place (8). But it is a fact.

 

Simple Steps to protect yourself: 2 learn logical thinking

Someone once said common sense is less common than you think. I unfortunately agree. We were all given brains and these are our quite well equipped to defend themselves against ideas/concepts that are not correct. And logic is the tool that helps. The most important thing is of course to start by being skeptical, and take the time to think through things logically.

The first thing you should do is strip any statement to its basic components, like deconstruct something made of Lego, break it down to its basic components. You take the argument that has been proposed to you into its basic premises. Then you apply a logic technique to see where that gets you.

Deduction (9)

Deduction is the most reliable way to prove an argument or reject it. The key to deduction is to place the premises of an argument into a certain shape, and if the shape holds, then the argument is valid. For example: 

  • All B are A
  • C is B
  • Therefore, C is A

Now let me flesh this as an argument with premised and conclusion:

  • All humans are mortal
  • John is human
  • Therefore, John is mortal

How about this one?

  • All women have long hair
  • Jane is a woman
  • Therefore, Jane has long hair

What do you think of this one? The form is the same as above, but do you agree? You probably wouldn’t. The argument is valid, however, one of the premises is not True.

  • Not all women have long hair

While the shape of the argument is valid, because one of the premises is not true, therefore the argument itself is not sound; you cannot say with certainty that Jane has long hair because one of the premises is not true (Some women do not have long hair).

And that’s the thing about deduction, it provides as close to certainty as you can get, it is bullet proof.

You can see deduction as:

  • Take an accepted Theory/Proven Idea
  • Apply it to a specific case that fits
  • Generate a conclusion for that specific case

What if you have no accepted theory/proven idea?

Induction (10)

While deduction is bullet proof, induction is less so; it gives you a probabilistic answer.

is really yummy, no tummy issues

Let’s say that, like me, you are a fan of la-zi-ji (spicy chicken).

  • I ate la-zi-ji 10 times in the last 3 months and each time, I had tummy issues the next day
  • The spices in La-zi-ji can be potent to cause tummy issues
  • Therefore, causes tummy issues

 There are a few differences compared to deduction.

Here you start with some observations (eat la-zi-ji day 1, tummy issues day 2, 10 times in last 3 months), apply some analysis/theory (la-zi-ji spices may cause tummy issues) and derive a probabilistic conclusion.

What do you think of this induction, how strong is it?

To me it is not that strong. It can be improved by gathering more data:

  • Eat from different stalls to make sure it is not stall specific
  • How did your friends who also at la-zi-ji react? Or is it just you?
  • Was It really la-zi-ji, what else did you eat, maybe you also ordered cray fish and you have a mild allergy

In induction, you start from observations, samples and try to build a theory. How strong the theory depends on the size and quality of your observations/samples.

The other important thing here is, if the 11th time you at la-zi-ji, your tummy is ok the next day, then you can revise your theory to la-zi-ji may cause tummy issues, you lower the probability.

Abduction (11)(12)

No, I am not referring to kidnapping. Abductive reasoning is another logical tool you should equip yourself with.

Interestingly, this is the type of reasoning AI finds less easy.

Abduction starts with an observation, then you think of the various things that could explain the hypothesis, and postulate the one you find most likely.

An example will clarify things:

  • You find crumbs on the kitchen table and unwashed plate and glass in the sink
  • You think it is most likely that your flat mate had a midnight snack and was too lazy to clean up.

There are may other explanations that could fit:

  • You sleepwalk and had a midnight snack while asleep last night
  • A burglar came in and decided to have a midnight snack
  • Your flat mate is playing a practical joke on you

You simply picked the one you thought most likely, based on your experience.

It is important to be able to recognize which of these paths of logical reasoning you have taken, then you can understand how much certainty you can associate with your beliefs based on which process you used to reach them.

It may be confusing at first, but with some practice you will get it.

Furthermore, there is a clear progression from Abduction to Induction to Deduction


This is aligned with how discovery takes place and models are created and built all the way to implementation.

The extra problem in the fight for the real estate of your brain is that some people/bots are really good at masking bad arguments, tricking you in believing they are correct.

 

Simple Steps to Protect yourself 3: Identify Fallacies

I always say I am lazy; I actually think humans are lazy and it takes conscious effort sometimes not to be lazy. Fallacies are shortcuts that people may choose to take advantage of your laziness and implant some stuff surreptitiously into your brain.

There are many fallacies, I will only illustrate a couple of the most commonly used:

Appeal to Authority / Ad Verecundiam

This simply uses a famous person as authority figure to justify the argument. There are 2 flavours: False Authority

  • CR7 uses K water
  • CR7 is world famous
  • Therefore, K Water must be a great soft drink.

Nobody said CR7 was an authority in water, this is the world of influencers…

Anonymous authority

  • Scientists claim 5G is harmful
  • Scientists know what they are talking about
  • Hence 5G is harmful

Who is the scientist, where are the scientific papers?

Bandwagon/Ad Populum

People who have known me well are likely to have heard me respond angrily to Ad Populum arguments; they are basically: do this because everyone does so… No need to think, just follow the bandwagon.

  • Everyone buys extended warranties
  • Extended warranties are worth it
  • Therefore, I should buy one on my spice grinder

 Strawman

A strawman argument is used when someone’s argument is distorted by an opponent so that when the distorted argument is refuted by the opponent, they claim the original argument has been refuted. It can take many forms: over simplifying what someone said, taking it out of context… It is used very very often by politicians

Example:

  • I am against the mandatory sentence for drug mules
  • He is for allowing entry of drugs into the country

False Dichotomy

False dichotomy truly plays on laziness. It aims to wrongly simplify an argument into 2 possible solutions, one of which is not favourable so you pick the other, ignoring all other solutions.

Example:

  • Either you eat an apple a day, or you visit the doctor.
  • You choose.

Ad Hominem

Ad Hominem occurs when the person is attacked rather than the argument that the person is making.

Example: 

  • I don’t think this person can be trusted because he made a mistake last time

This has no impact on the argument the person presents, but the ad hominem attack to meant to damage the credibility of the argument by damaging that of the person making it.

There are many more fallacies, I have just highlighted a few I am sure that, if you think about it, you have seen in action before. You can find more details; Wikipedia is a good place to start (13).

Conclusion

The best way to minimize chances of your brain being taken over by ideas/concepts that are not that correct is to learn to identify these ideas/concepts/arguments/snippets of ‘information’ as early as possible. You can rely on public service websites that check for truth, or choose to verify the veracity/soundness/validity of arguments by your own self, or both.

It is equally important to verify your beliefs in light of new data you may come across and update your beliefs/ideas. It is a constant battle, probably worth being engaged in.

 

  1. https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:7216242124814524417/
  2. https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/basics/trust
  3. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/337877932_Conspiracism_and_Delegitimation_A_lot_of_people_are_saying_The_new_conspiracism_and_the_assault_on_democracy_Russell_Muirhead_and_Nancy_Rosenblum_Princeton_University_Press_Princeton_2019_978069118883
  4. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/article/2024/jun/29/closing-the-stanford-internet-observatory-will-edge-the-us-towards-the-end-of-democracy
  5. https://cyber.fsi.stanford.edu/io
  6. https://www.politifact.com/
  7. https://library.csi.cuny.edu/c.php?g=619342&p=4310783
  8. https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/courts-crime/3b-money-laundering-case-su-jianfeng-sentenced-to-17-months-last-of-10-to-be-sent-to-jail
  9. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deductive_reasoning
  10. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inductive_reasoning
  11. I am using the classical definition of abduction here, as first explained by Pierce https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/abduction/peirce.html
  12. For a modern definition, you can consult https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/abduction/  ; however, I think the classical definition works best in the process of formulating ideas and also as part of the process of Analytics.
  13. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fallacies


Monday, 8 July 2024

Do you want to use AI or be used via AI? (1/2)

This is the first of 2 blog posts on giving some idea of how AI is being used, by who, and the choice each one of us as individuals has to make.

Right up front let me state my position:

  • Influencing how people behave is nothing new, AI just makes it easier to achieve
  • AI is being used more and more to influence how people think and therefore behave
  • AI is neither good nor bad, it is how it is used that matters.
  • Each one of us has a choice to make, whether to allow the influence or question it.

Influencing how people behave is nothing new, and this comes from everywhere


The ‘father of propaganda’, Edward Burnays (1), in his book Propaganda (2), he started by saying:

“The conscious and intelligent manipulation of the organized habits and opinions of the masses is an important element in democratic society. Those who manipulate this unseen mechanism of society constitute an invisible government which is the true ruling power of our country.”

And he continued by saying

“We are governed, our minds are molded, our tastes formed, and our ideas suggested, largely by men we have never heard of”

Edward Burnays was a psychologist and his book was first published in 1928. Burnays talks about state level molding of minds and suggestion of ideas.

States have always been very active in the field. I was actually very interested to see that Burnays was involved in United Fruit in South America. But that’s another topic. For today, we focus on how state and state agents influence us.

Nation/State-wide propaganda powered by AI/ML, bots

US presidential elections, since 2016

Some people may remember the idea that Russia was accused of spreading ‘selective information’ with a view to influence voters in the US elections in 2016 (3), 2020 (4). Various techniques were used and of course ML and AI were used, in managing bots, microtargeting (after having hacked personal details for example)(5). It was a well executed plan:

  • Hack into electoral registries especially in states with tight races
  • Get personal details of voters and how to contact them
  • Model how they could be influenced and prepare bots with selected information
  • Take action 

In 2016, Mr Trump won the elections, this was supposedly the aim of the 2016 effort.

In 2020, the ‘left wingers’ also started to get active in the bot space, although not as much as the right wing (5)


It is clear that the volume of tweets by ‘left-leaning bots’ was much lower than ‘right-leaning bots’ (and the pattern very different), but still there were efforts to ‘inform’ the electorate from both sides.

Foreign powers too

One of the most interesting aspects of the 2016 presidential elections was the emergence of the Russian interference claims (6) The idea was that Russia intervened to increase the chances of Mr Trump getting elected. The playbook was simple:

  • Hack electoral register (7)
  • Gather information about electors
  • Target them via bots

This also happened in 2020 (8), but prewarned the efforts were less one-sided.

2024 US Presidential elections

Already various sources are warning that Russia will be enhancing its impact by using AI more, and in 2024, China too is getting in on the game (9)(10); with Generative AI (GenAI), the impact is getting potentially stronger.

Interestingly, the aims of the efforts of China and Russia seems to differ. While Russia aims to weaken support for Ukraine in US, China aims at societal polarization (as if that needed a helping hand) (11).

But it is not only foreign national intelligence who are using AI, at least the Republican party is doing it to increase its appeal to specific voting groups (12) and democrats too (13).

Basically, everyone is using AI to fool American voters into doing their bidding.

Now, please do not believe that the USA is only a victim.

USA Military and the drive to hamper Covid19 vaccination in Philippines and Central Asia

A recent piece of research by Reuters uncovered that the Pentagon (USA ‘Ministry of Defence’) was using social media, fake accounts and presumably ML/AI tools, to turn people against taking the Covid19 vaccine from China (14)

In Singapore, the Chinese made vaccine (Sinovac) was made available, as well as Pfizer, Moderna, and is still available until now.

Now, what makes things more interesting is the polar opposite approach between the policies of the USA government (USA first, all vaccines possible to the USA) and China (Covid19 is a worldwide problem so avail vaccines to other countries).

Given the political position taken by the government, the Pentagon decided that they should not allow China to get any goodwill by giving away Covid19 vaccines. That would put the USA in a bad light. Hence, the disinformation campaign.

“Through phony internet accounts meant to impersonate Filipinos, the military’s propaganda efforts morphed into an anti-vax campaign. Social media posts decried the quality of face masks, test kits and the first vaccine that would become available in the Philippines – China’s Sinovac inoculation.”(14) Actually, this quote from the article would even point to more than just anti-China, since it is also about mask wearing. But for now, let’s focus on the pentagon’s anti-China vaccine stance.


Not only Philippines, but also in Central Asia, using religion

“Tailoring the propaganda campaign to local audiences across Central Asia and the Middle East, the Pentagon used a combination of fake social media accounts on multiple platforms to spread fear of China’s vaccines among Muslims at a time when the virus was killing tens of thousands of people each day. A key part of the strategy: amplify the disputed contention that, because vaccines sometimes contain pork gelatin, China’s shots could be considered forbidden under Islamic law.” By whatever means possible, the Pentagon discouraged adoption of Sinovac in Central Asia using rumours about religious taboos.

To me the key difference is that this campaign is real, and has probably cost people their lives: “When he addressed the vaccination issue, the Philippines had among the worst inoculation rates in Southeast Asia. Only 2.1 million of its 114 million citizens were fully vaccinated – far short of the government’s target of 70 million. By the time Duterte spoke, COVID cases exceeded 1.3 million, and almost 24,000 Filipinos had died from the virus. The difficulty in vaccinating the population contributed to the worst death rate in the region.”

‘“We weren’t looking at this from a public health perspective,” said a senior military officer involved in the program. “We were looking at how we could drag China through the mud.”’

In sum, chances are many Filipinos (and Central Asians) died because they chose not to take Sinovac that was available to them at the time because they were influenced by the Pentagon’s propaganda campaign using social media and bots. But don’t blame the tools. The aim of the campaign was achieved, the tools worked.

‘Deep Fake’, for a cause, the case of Pakistan

I used ’Deep Fake’ because in this case, AI was used to have an the voice of Mr Imran Khan make a speech, but the key is that Mr Khan was in prison and had passed his speech to his supporters to create the movies for the purpose of campaigning; an approved deep fake in a way(15).


This novel campaign strategy (16) was effective enough for Mr Khan and his allies to become the largest single block in Pakistan, although they did not manage to form the government (17)

This is a case where AI was used very effectively to bridge a gap between a politician and his electorate.

And to me, the key is that the electors knew exactly that this was an AI generated image of Mr Khan, but saying the words Mr Khan wants to say.

It worked.

What's next, an AI candidate/elected representative?

As far fetched as it may seem, it is quite a possibility, especially where candidates need not prove they are real humans, that you will get an AI aided or generated candidate near you. A recent case, in the 2024 UK Elections, Reform UK has been accused of fielding 'fake' candidates (18)



What does this mean?

It’s very simple, not only are private companies trying to influence our decisions, usually to buy/consume their products/services by using tools like AI, governments and the political class are also quickly adopting these tools.

The reason is that your brain is the hottest real estate, and everyone wants to plant a flag.

You may be ok with that or you may not.

The second part of this blog will show a couple of ways how each one of us could preserve this real estate.


  1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edward_Bernays
  2. https://singapore.kinokuniya.com/products?is_searching=true&keywords=propaganda&taxon=2
  3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_interference_in_the_2016_United_States_elections
  4. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_interference_in_the_2020_United_States_elections
  5. https://arxiv.org/pdf/2102.08436
  6. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_interference_in_the_2016_United_States_elections
  7. https://www.universal-rights.org/recent-us-report-of-russian-election-interference-reveals-how-disinformation-can-exploit-existing-divides-to-erode-trust-in-democracy/
  8. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_interference_in_the_2020_United_States_elections
  9. https://www.npr.org/2024/05/15/1251684195/election-interference-russia-china-senate-aritifical-intelligence
  10. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/technology/tech-news/microsoft-on-how-russia-and-china-are-using-ai-social-media-to-influence-upcoming-us-elections/articleshow/109382624.cms
  11. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/technology/tech-news/microsoft-on-how-russia-and-china-are-using-ai-social-media-to-influence-upcoming-us-elections/articleshow/109382624.cms
  12. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-68440150
  13. https://www.npr.org/2024/05/23/nx-s1-4977582/fcc-ai-deepfake-robocall-biden-new-hampshire-political-operative
  14. https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/usa-covid-propaganda/
  15. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8OiLFzf7uJw
  16. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-67752610
  17. https://edition.cnn.com/2024/02/21/asia/pakistan-announce-coalition-government-intl-hnk/index.html
  18. https://www.theguardian.com/politics/article/2024/jul/08/reform-uk-under-pressure-to-prove-all-its-candidates-were-real-people





 


Sunday, 30 June 2024

(A)ML: is it worth it?

I worked in banks for a while, as an employee and as a consultant, and one thing the banks make sure you are aware of is Money Laundering. Money Laundering is something all banking employees are tested and reminded of.

But for what?

A little piece of interesting news, most of the people involved in the multi-million money laundering case in Singapore surrendered 95.5% of their assets and got sentences of under 2 years in Singapore jails (1), no financial penalty (assuming assets were ‘illegally obtained’), short jail term. So, it doesn’t seem it’s a big deal, right?

What actually is the problem with money laundering?

First, let’s take a step back. This blogpost was motivated by the recent multi billion money laundering case in Singapore.

A recent article entitled “the banks that hold most money in Singapore’s largest Money Laundering Scandal“ (2) shows the extent that banks in Singapore, not only the big 3 local banks (UOB, DBS, OCBC) manage bank accounts of the people found guilty of money laundering (49.6M, 29M, 22.4M), but also large international banks such as Credit Suisse, CitiGroup, (79.6M, 79.3M).

Credit Suisse is not a stranger to money laundering (3), the case of Bulgarian cocaine with the judge commenting that “the company could have prevented the infringement if it had fulfilled its organizational obligations” and yes, Credit Suisse is now owned by UBS, but UBS is not that vigilant regarding money laundering either (4). As for CitiGroup, this again would not be the first time (5).

The local banks were involved in the 1MDB and wirecard scandals (6)(7).

So, banks have been involved in Money Laundering, again and again.

Millions are spent by banks yearly to buy, maintain, upgrade their Anti Money Laundering (AML) systems. It is a very very lucrative market to be in. Free Money once you get in, since in most cases, banks are forced to show their AML capabilities to regulators, and having a shiny AML system is something most regulators would not question.


The Singapore case

The first thing that came to my mind when I read about the case was, how on earth did the great AML systems not pick these as possible money laundering cases. Do you see a pattern among the cases? And more importantly, even before knowing some of these people are involved in “interesting” activities, don’t you find it a bit weird and worth a second look? One early article focused on this aspect “”(8)

“Ten people of Cypriot, Turkish, Chinese, Cambodian and Ni-Vanuatu nationalities were charged on Wednesday (Aug 16) night after police conducted simultaneous raids across Singapore as part of a probe into money laundering and forgery offences.”

And to add to this, another piece of news from Singapore about someone also belonging to the same very specific demographic group, this time about someone who created malware that infected many computers and caused large losses (9)

“The DOJ said that Wang, who also holds a St Kitts and Nevis citizenship, allegedly received US$99 million from cyber criminals who tapped his network from 2018 to July 2022.”

Now you can say that the world is now so open, having multiple nationalities, even for Chinese citizens is not a big deal, but is it?

China does not recognise dual nationality, according to the Nationality Law of the People’s Republic of China (10) which clearly states:

Article 3: The People’s Republic of China does not recognize dual nationality for any Chinese national

Everyone in Singapore knows of rich Chinese nationals who took up Singaporean nationality such as the bosses of Hai Di Lao (11), TsingShan Holdings (12), SEA holdings (Shopee is a subsidiary) (13) and their families. However, with all due respect, having Singapore as Nationality and say Vanuatu (14) are 2 very different things.

Why don’t sophisticated AML models used by these large banks fail to flag rich Chinese nationals having multi million dollars in assets but with ‘exotic’ passports.

Even if this may be a relatively recent phenomenon, and AML models, being trained on past data may take a while to pick up this characteristic (ahum…), you would have thought humans would take a deeper look into the sources of income of these people during the Know Your Customer (KYC) that is compulsory when accepting new customers, and their transactions. But, in the case of the Singapore based money launderers, they were allowed to purchase many properties easily, avoiding all AML models and human oversight (if any).

AML Models as a shield

And that’s the second thing, do banks use AML models as a shield? so they only get into minor trouble when money laundering is discovered? “Hey, check out my shiny AML model Regulator, it cost me millions, I am doing what I can in terms of AML”. After all, these money launderers must have paid hefty fees to banks while moving their millions, and buying their properties.

As far as I have seen, the only person who got into trouble related to transactions of the Money Launderers are the property agents, with one fined $4000 (15) which is likely a minor portion of what that agent earned on these cases. But there is noise about the rot going further into private banking sector, although no action has been taken yet (16). The only agent who faced the law seriously, was found to have behaved above board in the real estate transaction although her issues were unrelated (17).

To reiterate, getting involved in Money Laundering is no biggie, jail terms and financial wise

So, not only do the perpetrators of money laundering get minor jail sentences, for reference, 4 Vietnamese nationals who shoplifted items of 60,000 times less value, including a pregnant woman, were jailed more than 20 months each (more than the longest jail term for the money laundering) (18), and I am pretty sure the clothes shoplifted were restituted since these foreigners were caught while still in Singapore.

Should you be surprised?

No. Actually I didn’t think about it before, but money laundering is not something that serious, as the sentences showed.

I will go further… My brother told me “you think like a criminal” when I told him this, but, it is a risk worth taking. Imagine, even 1pct of SGD3b is still SGD30m... if I have this stashed somewhere, I will go there and enjoy cold sakes in summer and warm sakes in winter until my sunset.

To add to this, please note that at least 1 of the men sentenced went to Japan after release from jail in Singapore(19), it is highly unlikely they are wanted for anything in Japan.

Think about it.

Who were the victims of the money laundering?

-        The previous owners of the properties/assets purchased got to keep their funds from laundered money

-        Real estate and other agents who facilitated transactions usually got small fines (for reference a real estate agent may be charges 2% commission; for a SGD4,000 fine that would break even at a property worth SGD200,000.

-        Banks get to sell the assets mortgaged and recoup their loans and do not have to return their transaction fees

-        Bankers keep their bonuses

-        Even the government made via duties, fees, and taxes (whether directly or indirectly)

I don’t see anyone in Singapore worse off.

So we are back full circle.

What is the problem with money laundering?

Referring to the Singapore multi billion dollar case, presumably, the issue is the source of the funds these people brought into Singapore. The people somehow made Singaporean entities believe (ahum…) these were from legitimate means, but they were not.

Money Laundering is a possible symptom of non legal activities having taken place. A possible tail-end part of a chain of transactions, one of which was possibly illegal.

The real problem is the presumably illegal transaction that generated the money to be laundered. Money laundering basically means taking money that is not registered in the legal economy and making it legally registered so that it can be used. The trick is that the amounts are huge; we could easily launder a few thousand dollars by living our normal life in a year, but if it was a million it would be harder, hence the need for large transactions, property, investments…

But the fact is, the laundering itself, doesn’t seem to harm many. It is the failure to detect and stop the illegal transaction themselves (that possibly cause harm such as adulterated drug dealing, scamming( Around 45,000 Singapore scam victims lost $600m last year(20)), gun and weapons dealing (ahum…interestingly Singapore has managed to cut trade of weapons to Myanmar (banned) by 90% recently (21))) that are the issue. The failure to stop these demonises money laundry, it is an easy way out.

What to do regarding money laundering then?

Radically, allow all transactions 😊, then there will be no need to launder, all transactions can be taxed appropriately (ahum… there really seems to be something lodged in my throat…) and nobody worse off. However, this is quite impractical.

The key is to first decide whether money laundering is really such a big deal.

From the example above, it seems that money laundering is not as bad as shoplifting. If that is the case, then there should be less focus in banks and financial institutions around money laundering, and money should be spent elsewhere. Since many banks getting involved in money laundering, and even more than once and/or over a period of time, and their business does not seem to suffer much, there is no incentive for them to do something about it, and spending on ‘state of the art’ AML systems is just a waste of money, especially when humans are kept out of the loop, whether willfully or not.

If money laundering is seen as worse than shoplifting, then the whole penalty set should be increased accordingly for people who actively launder money, and people and organisations that enable them such as real estate companies, private banks… A slap on the wrist of the people on the ground is obviously not sufficient.

A few days ago, the Monetary Authority of Singapore updated AML guidelines (22). Personally, sorry for being cynical, I do not think that this incentivises financial institutions to really do something, it is more of an advisory nature, neither carrot, and especially not a stick to change behaviour. At most there are more areas for AML software companies to sell their wares.

As a rough guide, in 12 months of 2022-23, Singapore financial institutions spent more than SGD7.5B 'to fight crime and meet regulatory obligations' (23)

Update:

The people found guilty of the SGD3B money laundering case used Family Offices (Offices that basically only manage a family's financial affairs, these do not fall under financial regulator (MAS) purview), and they even got tax breaks. (24) These tax breaks will not be clawed back.


  1. https://straitstimes.com/singapore/courts-crime/3b-money-laundering-case-su-jianfeng-sentenced-to-17-months-last-of-10-to-be-sent-to-jail
  2. https://sg.finance.yahoo.com/news/the-banks-that-hold-most-money-in-singapore-largest-laundering-scandal-220006461.html
  3. https://www.morningstar.hk/hk/news/233221/credit-suisses-demise-a-timeline-of-scandal-and-failures.aspx
  4. https://www.finews.com/news/english-news/62808-ubs-money-laundering-edf-mros-yemen-ali-abdullah-saleh
  5. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/22/business/dealbook/citigroup-settlement-banamex-usa-inquiry.html
  6. https://www.mas.gov.sg/-/media/MAS/News-and-Publications/Press-Releases/Summary-of-1MDB-Related-Court-and-Regulatory-Actions_as-at-30May17.pdf
  7. https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/singapore-fines-dbs-citibank-ocbc-swiss-life-inadequate-money-laundering-2023-06-21/
  8. https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/money-laundering-suspects-police-probe-raids-gcb-condo-prime-areas-seized-3703491
  9. https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/chinese-national-arrested-in-s-pore-for-creating-malware-that-allowed-criminals-to-steal-billions
  10. https://cn.ambafrance.org/IMG/pdf/loi_nationalite_chine.pdf
  11. https://www.straitstimes.com/business/property/haidilao-co-founder-shi-yonghong-buys-dr-lee-wei-lings-cluny-hill-gcb-for-50-million
  12. https://mothership.sg/2024/04/tsingshan-founder-daughter-84-million-gcb/
  13. https://theindependent.sg/sea-ceo-forrest-lis-wife-to-buy-gcb-on-gallop-road-for-s42-5m/
  14. https://www.dailypost.vu/news/citizenship-office-wont-decide-on-wanted-citizen-until-court-conviction-kapapa/article_17d821fa-6ce6-5f6b-a484-638dc9c15897.html
  15. https://www.businesstimes.com.sg/singapore/economy-policy/2-property-agents-found-guilty-failing-carry-out-anti-money-laundering
  16. https://www.singaporelawwatch.sg/Headlines/agents-gave-kickbacks-bankers-took-cuts-ethics-flew-out-the-window-in-money-launderers-deals
  17. https://mothership.sg/2024/01/rochelle-chow-shuting-license-not-renewed/
  18. https://asiatimes.com/2018/12/four-jailed-for-singapore-shoplifting-spree/
  19. https://www.channelnewsasia.com/Singapore/3-deported-japan-cambodia-billion-dollar-money-laundering-case-4380856
  20. https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/courts-crime/scam-victims-in-s-pore-lost-6518m-in-2023-with-record-high-of-over-46000-cases-reported Stopping scams, or at least quickly catching scam centres is something that Analytics/ML/AI can help do relatively easily with the right data. The way exists, but the will is weak.
  21. https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/weapons-arms-flow-singapore-myanmar-junta-dropped-dramatically-united-nations-envoy-tom-andrews-4439181
  22. https://www.mas.gov.sg/news/media-releases/2024/singapore-publishes-updated-money-laundering-national-risk-assessment
  23. https://www.straitstimes.com/business/singapore-financial-firms-spent-more-fighting-crime-and-meeting-regulatory-demands
  24. https://sg.news.yahoo.com/6-family-office-funds-tied-to-singapore-launder-case-got-tax-breaks-075431904.html

Thursday, 13 June 2024

Data Culture: why NCS servers being accessed by fired employee multiple times over 3 months is scary

If you had a place where you kept your barang-barang/bric-a-brac/bits-n-pieces, even detached, would you keep it unlocked/unlatched while latching and locking the rest of your home?

I was actually planning a blog on the multi-billion-dollar money laundering case in Singapore, when this piece of news came out in the open, the case of the disgruntled NCS employee. Laundry can wait.



Some facts as they have been released (1)

Background

1 NCS (2) is owned by Singtel group

2 NCS focuses on applications, cybersecurity, infrastructure and engineering

3 NCS serves corporates, Telco (since is owned by Singtel) and more pertinently Government. In fact, up to 66% of NCS $2.7B revenue was from government (3) and as recently as this year NCS was still focused on government (4)

4 Singtel is also a major player in GXS bank, together with Grab.

Mr Nagaraju

5 Mr Nagaraju was employed by NCS from November 2021

6 Mr Nagaraju was fired by NCS in October 2022, with an effective last day of Nov 16 2022.

7 Mr Nagaraju went back to India

8 Between Jan 6 2023 and Jan 17 2023, Mr Nagaraju accessed NCS servers using Administrator privileges 6 times.

9 Mr Nagaraju found a new job in Singapore in February 2023 and came back to Singapore, living with an ex NCS colleague

10 He used the “wifi” and accessed NCS systems again in February 2023

11 In March 2023, a full 3 months after he had been fired, Mr Nagaraju accessed the NCS systems 13 times and deleted some virtual servers.

12 Mr Nagaraju was arrested in April 2023

13 He was sentenced to 2 years and 8 months jail

14 NCS apparently made a loss of SGD918,000.


The press reaction

Mainstream media is portraying this case as a disgruntled ex-employee causing almost SGD1m damage to the ex-employer. This misses the point.

Assuming 66% of NCS revenue came from government, that’s $1.7B that the government has paid NCS in 2023 for services. Hence a lot of data that pertains to Singapore residents, likely including Personally Identifiable Information, is kept in systems possibly built (infrastructure and engineering), managed (applications) and secured (cybersecurity) by NCS. This should be the story.

I am sure some people will argue that the systems that Mr Nagaraju had access to were not government systems but systems internal to NCS. Yes, but so what? If you cannot keep your own house in order, how can you help keep someone else’s? What type of governance does NCS have on it systems?


Think about it:

1 Mr Nagaraju accessed systems after he was fired, the HR system is likely not to be properly integrated with the other systems. Also note, he was fired, he did not resign voluntarily. This is really weird because in a previous project I was involved in, we did have to integrate with an HR system to control accesses systematically.

2 He accessed systems from India even. Hence there is no geographical restriction as to who can access NCS systems. While this is a good thing to allow employees to work from home or take care of emergencies, there should be some monitoring taking place, not a half-yearly review after the horses have bolted.

3 It is not mentioned whether he used an NCS device or his own personal device from India to access the systems; personal devices can be secured and 3 months is past most cases for reviewing accessed for personal devices. If he had an NCS laptop, again, the processes to secure the devices failed, and the device access was not cut.

4 He had admin powers and admin credentials. Either, again, his ID’s access to systems was not terminated, not something new. You would have thought lessons would have been learnt. Or it was a shared ID and password, a major no-no in the IT world. Basically NCS controls and governance on IDs and passwords and accesses were severely lacking. Not that I am saying NCS was the IT vendor, but even in 2017 the AG reviewed 2 critical government services (Ministry of Defence MINDEF, and Ministry of Manpower MOM, and Singapore Customs) and found similar lapses in IDs (5)

In brief, this case shows how bad the controls of NCS were. And I think it is legitimate to ask how likely this culture has affected the projects for which they earned around SGD1.7B in 2023 from the government.

I am sure nobody in SG has forgotten about the IHIS/SingHealth issues where even the then PM’s data was searched (6).

To me, focusing on close to SGD1M ‘losses’ to NCS is a red herring. And I would like to ask, isn’t NCS aware of back-ups? Apparently NCS only discovered the servers missing when someone tried to log into one of them the day after Mr Nagaraju deleted it. SGD1M worth of damage, I would find it hard to believe unless there are no back-ups. That would be another horror story on how NCS managed its servers.

Conclusion

I think it is important to understand that the real story is not the SGD1M NCS supposedly lost, but the fact that their governance, processes and security practices leave much to be desired.

It's all about culture: is securing your company's assets in your blood?

Data is crucial, especially when more and more government services are moving online. We trust certain organisations to keep our data safe, and they choose vendors who, we hope, will do so. Personally, when I see a major vendor for these government organisations having a loose data culture, I fear for my data.


  1. https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/former-employee-hack-ncs-delete-virtual-servers-quality-testing-4402141
  2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NCS_Group
  3. https://www.singtel.com/about-us/investor-relations/annual-report-fy2023/ncs-ceo-review
  4. https://www.zdnet.com/article/ncs-looks-beyond-government-singapore-for-transformation-growth/
  5. https://tnp.straitstimes.com/news/singapore/government-audit-finds-lapses-it-controls-unchecked-vendors
  6. https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/personal-info-of-15m-singhealth-patients-including-pm-lee-stolen-in-singapores-most

Sunday, 9 June 2024

Thinking Analytically: the case of Mr Shariff Uddin

I mentioned to someone recently that I believed analytics is an application using tools of a way of thinking. To think analytically is something that can be learnt/taught, and once you have that, tools don’t matter that much; hey you still need to know what questions to ask GenAI, no?

To give an example, I look at the case of Mr Shariff Uddin, a Bangladeshi author who was living and working in Singapore and recently left Singapore under less than clear circumstances.

Who is Mr Shariff Uddin?

Did you know that someone on a work permit authored (1) a book about his experiences as a work permit holder in Singapore, and won the prize for non-fiction in Singapore (2)

A fascinating, challenging and truly important book. Not only do we now at long last have access to the most sustained and authentic narrative and record of life and work as a Bengali migrant in 21st century Singapore, but also a genuine work of art in its own right. Sharif is an unprecedented and crucial voice in Singapore writing: perceptive, joyful, critical, constructive. With his characteristic modesty, he has something of moment to tell us and he does so from the heart beautifully.

– Richard Angus Whitehead, Lecturer, English Language and Literature Department, National Institute of Education

Mr Uddin has left Singapore. The aim of this blog is to explore his case using data-driven lens, and see what you think is the issue.

 


Background on the case

Things started falling apart early this year while Mr Uddin has been working in Singapore for 16 years. His employer started receiving threats from loansharks alleging Mr Uddin had borrowed money from them and failed to repay the debts.

From threats at the work place, things escalated to informing the other tenants of the work place, and eventually also to the home of the business owner and even to the business owner’s sister. (3)

There have been a few controversies in this case. The most interesting one was that Mr Uddin argued that the police and/or the Ministry of Manpower advised his employer to terminate his employment, as stated in his termination letter

“under police and MOM officer advice ... because of the troublesome bring along from your loan shark issue for us”(4)

Something the authorities vigorously denied (4). It turned out, something that is not contested, that the police officer whom the business owners talked to at Geylang Police Post as per this official Facebook post (5) “The officer, out of concern for her family’s and her well-being, also advised her generally that harassment would usually stop after the work pass of a foreign worker being harassed had been cancelled, and the worker no longer worked for the employer.”.

There has been some confusion whether the lady involved was the sister or daughter of the business owner was the person involved, as you can see the MoM refers to daughter (5) but the business owner says sister (3).

And importantly, the Police investigation found no evidence that Mr Uddin borrowed anything from loan sharks, hence the harassment was totally unfounded as Mr Uddin had been saying all along - Investigations eventually concluded with the authorities finding no evidence that Mr Sharif had borrowed money from unlicensed lenders. -(3)

I am not a social crusader so what does this case have to do with data?


What data?

Data does not mean just things on a spreadsheet, but pieces of information

  1. Mr Uddin’s details (presumably including his work permit number and employer) were used to obtain a loan from a loanshark
  2. the loan shark decided, as per usual practice, to harass the debtor where he/she can be damaged, here the place of employment
  3. they went further by informing other tenants
  4. they went even further and obtained information on where the sister of the employer lives, and caused harassment there. This is important, it is not the employer’s home but the sister’s.
  5. Mr Uddin was terminated by his employer
  6. Mr Uddin found a new employer who also received threats and as per the reports (3) only the first employer and MoM were aware of this new job offer
  7. Mr Uddin found no other suitable alternative employment
  8. At the expiry of his extended pass, he left Singapore.

 

Who dunnit?

This is kind of the information we have, so now the question is what is likely to be the most likely interpretation?

  • Mr Uddin took a loan from a loanshark and fed the him/her information, he is responsible
  • Mr Uddin took a loan from a loanshark with long arms and was hell bent chasing Mr Uddin out.
  • One or more people with access to government systems leaked information
  • Mr Uddin’s employer wanted Mr Uddin to leave Singapore

 

Actually…

Actually, I have no idea which is the correct interpretation, but I have a fairly good idea how this can be resolved. Since it is common for loansharks to obtain photocopies of NRIC/FIN/WP in order to give a loan, all parties have some reason to have access to the data.

The keys are

-        Address of the sister of the employer; the employer claims it is via her car plate number (LTA system)

-        Details of new employer of Mr Uddin

I have no clue who has access to what data in the government systems. In a nutshell:

  • MoM databases should hold data related to employees and people on various passes in Singapore, and data on the change in the passes.
  • ACRA should have access to directorships, including directors’ addresses, but not family members details.
  • LTA should have access to car owners’ data, and that includes vehicles owned by both individuals and corporations and as such some information on company directorships, but not comprehensively.
  • The Police force database should have access to multiple databases, or even copies of their data such as ICA who controls identity of everyone in Singapore

I assume that information is siloed, but even if it is not, access to information should be on need to now basis. And since this is considered PII, should fall under PDPA (although the government if exempted (6)), and at the very least all data requests for PII information should be logged and thus traceable.

Hence, to resolve the issue and find some justice for Mr Uddin, all that is required is the logs for say April onwards for the agencies above and understand who made requests for

  • New employer of Mr Uddin
  • Address of the sister of Mr Uddin’s previous employer

These 2 pieces of information should suffice in resolving the issues.

It is not rocket science, it is basic analysis.

 

Conclusion

There are 2 conclusions:

The case is closed, but to me some grey areas remain. They may not be of help to Mr Uddin, but intrinsically I believe it would be important to know what data in the various agencies has not been misused without detection.

It’s not very difficult to think of simple things analytically, is it?



  1. https://www.landmarkbooks.sg/md-sharif-uddin
  2. https://www.landmarkbooks.sg/store/p/stranger-to-myself
  3. https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/uddin-sharif-loanshark-hiap-seng-piling-construction-4385606
  4. https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/migrant-worker-fired-loan-sharks-bangladeshi-sharif-md-uddin-4247646
  5. https://www.facebook.com/sgministryofmanpower/posts/784330097132347
  6. https://www.straitstimes.com/politics/parliament-public-agencies-not-governed-by-pdpa-because-of-fundamental-differences-in-how